BETWEEN A ROCK AND A HARD PLACE REVIEWED


Remember what caused the ongoing war with Hamas in the Gaza Strip?

On October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorists waged the deadliest attack on Jews since the Holocaust — slaughtering babies, committing sexual violence, burning whole families alive, and taking over 250 civilians hostage. Hamas murdered more than 1,200 Israelis during the attack.

The area known today as the Gaza Strip was allocated in the 1947 UN Partition Plan for a prospective Arab state. Its borders were based on the ceasefire line that ended the fighting after the 1948 War of Independence. The failure of further diplomatic efforts to end the Arab-Israeli conflict turned, what was intended to be a temporary armistice line, into a de-facto boundary, and the Gaza Strip into a distinct geopolitical entity.

Locked in one of the world’s most densely populated areas, along with unsettled political status, Gaza has always been a focal point of the Israeli-Arab conflict. It has also been, perhaps, the most controversial and  divisive issue in Israel itself.

In the 1956 Suez War, David Ben-Gurion, who was then the Defense Minister, ordered the IDF to capture the Gaza Strip and most of Sinai. His own Chief of Staff, Moshe Dayan, opposed the plan to take over Gaza. Because of international pressure, Ben-Gurion felt forced to give up his plan to incorporate the Gaza Strip into Israeli territory. He  wrote a heartfelt apology to the southern settlements (situated close to the Gaza borders) which, for the first time, had been able to work their fields in safety  and  to sleep peacefully.

The chairman of the opposition Herut party, Menachem Begin, wrote: “Sisters and brothers in the Negev,  my heart goes out to you…. The chairman of Mapai (Labour Party), has withdrawn and abandoned you, your blood will flow like water….. Your settlements will no longer be protected.”

Not only Begin and the Herut party objected to the Gaza withdrawal. General Yigal Allon, a brilliant military leader and a member of Ben-Gurion’s Labour Party leading politician, declared in 1956: “Gaza is Israeli no less than Jaffa. Let us rightfully be prepared to defend the Gaza Strip as we would be to defend Be’er Sheba.”

Major General Aharon Doron, commander of the battalion slated to take over Gaza gave an inspiring speech to his soldiers: “Gaza, a living organ in the body of the State of Israel, which has been torn from it………. Gaza, Khan Yunis and their inhabitants are an organic part of the state…”

Three years after the Six-day War the Southern Commander, General Ariel Sharon declared: “Holding on to the Nahal post in Kfar Darom is vital, not only for security reasons, but to disillusion the Arabs in Gaza that we will leave Gaza any time in the future.” The same Ariel Sharon who was the Prime Minister responsible for the forced evacuation of all the settlements in the Gaza Strip in 2005!

In 1972, a resolution accepted  by the government of President Golda Meyer stipulated: “A safe border between Israel and Egypt necessitates changes in the previous international border,  taking for granted that we will hold on to the Gaza Strip in Israeli territory.”

For once there was almost 100% consensus between all parties that the Gaza Strip must be part of Israel. It didn’t last for long. This was followed by a fiery debate in a conference which took place within the far-left Zionist party. The few hundred participants  included the  Mapam Party and several left-wing kibbutzim situated close to the Gaza Strip. The “moving spirit” in the debate, which took place in kibbutz Nir-Oz - who was opposed to taking over Gaza - was one of the kibbutz members, Oded Lifshitz,  (one of the hostages killed by Hamas in 2023). From Nir Oz alone 47 members were murdered and 76 abducted on the same day !

Arguing with Oded Lipshitz was also a member of the same party, from kibbutz Beit Hashita, who was strongly opposed to the idea of withdrawing from Gaza. He declared: “Even if we agree that Gaza is a cancerous growth, and we operate to remove it from its body, it will remain a cancerous growth and will be more dangerous outside. It is a problem we must solve, and there is only one solution: to integrate it into Israel.

The proposal of withdrawing from the Gaza Strip is not a more humanitarian solution but bad, not only for us, but also for the Arabs. In another few years we will have to return and take over the Strip, and spill the blood of Jews as well as  of Arabs. If we return it today, there will be a next invasion - which will not be initiated by us, but we will be forced into - harsher and crueller.”

These prophetic words were stated in 1972. Since then, until today, there has been nothing but violence from the Gaza Strip.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A DIABOLICAL STRATEGY

It’s a verified fact that Hamas has been planning the ongoing war with Israel for decades. Hamas knew that they could not beat Israel militarily.  They also knew that  Israel would retaliate very strongly after the massacre on October 7 th - and the kidnapping and abuse of 252 men, women, children and babies. Hamas spent almost twenty years preparing the Gaza Strip as a killing ground for Israeli soldiers and Palestinian civilians. The  massive network of tunnels spanned more kilometers than the London Underground and  New York metro combined!  By integrating their military operations throughout civilian infrastructure - these tunnels served as missile launchers and storehouses of lethal weapons underneath kindergartens, schools, hospitals, even mosques, etc. The IDF had no choice but to fight the terrorists from, or close to, residential and commercial areas. In all those years, Hamas deliberately prepared nothing to protect it’s own civilians. On the co...
Read more

AN EVERLASTING LIGHT - I

Image
AN EVERLASTING LIGHT - I For all my new readers, I am rewriting a blog I wrote a few years ago, which is still relevant: Perhaps the most significant battle that the Jews fought, and won,  took place in the second century BCE.    Desiring to unify his kingdom through the medium of a common religion and culture Antiochus, the Greek ruler at that time, tried to root out the individualism of the Jews by desecrating their holy Temple and suppressing all the Jewish Laws. Tomorrow we start the eight day Festival commemorating this particular victory - this year coinciding exactly with Christmas. The story of Mattitiyahu Maccabee and his sons, who head the Revolt, is told in detail in the two books of the Maccabees.   A small, vastly outnumbered band of Jews waged battle against the mighty Greek armies, and drove them out of the land. Even though Judaism would have disappeared if Antiochus had succeeded in his strategy,  Jewish sages chose to leave these book...
Read more

METAMORPHOSIS IN THE MIDDLE EAST

After Hamas carried out its horrific October 7, 2023 massacre by invading Israel, murdering hundreds of people and kidnapping individuals from various countries, Israel reached a breaking point. This barbaric act of terrorism led to ground-breaking developments For decades, the Middle East has been plagued by violence and instability, but Israel's response marked a significant turning point, dramatically transforming the region. Israel, in its counteroffensive against Hamas, targeted and significantly diminished the terrorist group's military capabilities crippling its ability to function effectively. The Iranian regime, a staunch supporter of Hamas, was activating other proxies, Hezbollah in Lebanon and the Houthis in Yemen, to attack Israel. In an unprecedented move, Iran also launched ballistic missiles from Iranian soil into Israel, thereby escalating the conflict. Israel's broader objective appears to be, not merely to respond to isolated acts of terrorism, but...
Read more